1672-8505

CN 51-1675/C

人类生命科技的生命伦理风险类型及法治治理原则

Types of Bioethical Risks in Human Life Science and Technology and Principles of Legal Governance

  • 摘要: 面对人类生命科技飞速发展带来的生命伦理风险,现有个案分析与对策建议,仅仅停留在风险认知与治理争论层面,影响治理效能。因此,文章借鉴法学“类型化理论”,根据人类生命科技的过程,分为人类生命科学技术研究的生命伦理风险、科技成果运用的生命伦理风险与科技成果运用效果的生命伦理风险;根据人类生命科技的性质,分为治疗性技术的生命伦理风险、辅助生殖性技术的生命伦理风险、生产性技术的生命伦理风险;根据人类生命科技生命伦理风险的性质,分为确定性风险与不确定性风险。在专门法缺失的情况下,应当强化共识,首先确立人类生命科技的生命伦理风险法治治理原则。具体来说,可以坚持生命科学技术研究的限制原则、科技成果运用和运用效果的禁止原则;坚持治疗性技术和生产性技术的限制原则、生殖性技术的禁止原则;坚持确定性风险的禁止原则、不确定性风险的限制原则;坚持以网格化类型明确单独生命伦理风险法治治理原则的例外规定。

     

    Abstract: In response to the bioethical risks arising from the rapid development of human life sciences and technology, existing case analyses and proposed countermeasures primarily focus on risk perception and governance debates, which limits their effectiveness in practical governance. The "typology theory" in legal studies can be applied to categorize bioethical risks. Based on the process of human life sciences and technology, bioethical risks can be classified into (1) risks in life science and technology research, (2) risks arising from the application of scientific and technological achievements, and (3) risks associated with the effects of these applications. From the perspective of the nature of human life sciences and technology, risks can be further divided into (1) bioethical risks in therapeutic technologies, (2) bioethical risks in assisted reproductive technologies, and (3) bioethical risks in productive technologies. Additionally, bioethical risks can be categorized based on their certainty into (1) measurable risks and (2) uncertainty. In the absence of specialized legislation, it is essential to strengthen consensus and establish legal governance principles for bioethical risks in human life sciences and technology. Specifically, the following principles should be applied: (1) the restriction principle in life science and technology research, and the prohibition principle in the application of technological achievements; (2) the restriction principle for therapeutic and productive technologies, and the prohibition principle for reproductive technologies; and (3) the prohibition principle for certain risks, and the restriction principle for uncertain risks. Moreover, exceptions to these governance principles should be clearly defined through a grid-based categorization approach.

     

/

返回文章
返回